上帝会罚一个从未听说过他的人进地狱吗?
2019-10-19 叶良辰 20310
原文地址
原文地址:https://www.quora.com/Will-God-send-an-individual-who-has-never-heard-of-Him-to-hell
正文翻译
原创翻译:龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.com 翻译:叶良辰 转载请注明出处

Will God send an individual who has never heard of Him to hell?

上帝会罚一个从未听说过他的人进地狱吗?


评论翻译
原创翻译:龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.com 翻译:叶良辰 转载请注明出处

Nivethan Jeyasingam
These are the answers you will get from people of different religions, and an atheist!Atheist: lolwat?!Buddhist: First, I don''t care whether the god exists or not! So, "God sending people to Hell" is out of the spiritual context of Buddhism. Pleasures and pains are only based on our past actions (Karma). Hindu: No. Such an unfair entity can not be the god, and vice-versa. God treats all beings equally regardless of your path or knowledge about god. Pleasures and pains are only based on our past actions (Karma).As per Hinduism and Buddhism, Heaven and Hell are temporary places and self realization is the ultimate end. (Until that, the soul will born again and again in Heaven or Hell or Earth depending on its Karma)Christian: If you don''t accept Jesus as your God and Savior, you will go to hell no matter you heard about him or not (Some subsets of Christianity will differ in this opinion. Some Christians believe that all people will be given the chance to know about Jesus, so the scenario of not knowing Jesus does not exist in their view). Muslim: You will be sent to Hell if you don''t accept Prophet Muhammad as the final messenger of Allah (God). But, if you have not heard about Islam, you may not be sent to hell (Some Muslims will differ in this view). Sure hell guaranteed for Atheists and idol worshipers (Hindus, Buddhists). As for Christians, the ones who are following Christianity even after Allah sent his last messenger (Muhammad) will be sent to hell.What I said above is the popular opinion among the followers of these religions. It does not necessarily mean that those religious books really meant the mentioned meaning. Some/many followers take points from religious books literally than understanding the underlying significance (If any) obxtively.

回答1:
对于这个问题,各种宗教和无神论的答案如下:
无神论者: 呵呵,什么鬼东西?

佛教徒:首先,我不在乎上帝是否存在!
所以,“上帝是否送人下地狱”已经脱离了佛教的语境了.
佛教认为,一个人的快乐和痛苦,只决定于他过去的行为(昔日因,今时果).



Ed Cote
No. In the forty days after death, the soul is given a sort of guided tour of the afterlife. In that time, the demons try to make that person despair of salvation, while the angels call bullshit. It''s up to that person to decide whom to believe. Of course the way you live your life and the way you die inform your perceptions in and of that time. A good. honest, and wise person, even a pagan or atheist, will follow the angels, which usually means mea culpas and finally learning some perspective and humility. People who give in to despair or can''t check their egos follow the demons, and all too often that includes those who called themselves Christians.It really is up to that person more than anyone else, even God himself. He would let everyone in, but there are those who just can''t tolerate Him.
As for the people who lived and died before Jesus, both Jew and gentile alike, they did at first go to Hades, but at the time everyone did. That is only because Christ had not rejoined them to God. On Holy Saturday He was not sitting around feeling sorry for himself. He was in Hades, wading through the shit, flipping Satan the bird, and literally evangelizing the dead. Anyone willing to listen and follow him out of there on Sunday did, from Abraham himself to Confucius, Plato and Aristotle.

回答2:
不会,在死后的40天里,灵魂被给予了一种对来世的引导之旅。
在那个时候,魔鬼会试图让人的灵魂对救赎绝望,
而天使则对灵魂说,不要相信魔鬼.
到底应该相信天使还是魔鬼,这是由那个人的灵魂来决定的.
当然,你在世时的生活方式和死亡方式会影响到你当时的感知.
一个好人,诚实而明智的人,即使是异教徒或无神论者,此时也会追随天使的.
当然,追随天使也意味着这个灵魂会认错,忏悔自己的过错,学会谦卑,学会辨明是非.

而那些陷入绝望,或者无法克服自我的人,则往往会追随魔鬼.
这些人还包括那些自称自己的基督徒的人!
所以,一个人进地狱还是进天堂,真的会取决于他自己的决定,
其他人说了不算,包括上帝说了也不算.

任何人,上帝都会让他进天堂的,只是他自己不进而已.
至于耶稣降临诞生之前死去的人,无论是犹太人还是异教徒,
他们一开始确实都是进入地狱的,他们之所以入地狱,是因为那时所有人(死后)都要入地狱的.
原因是,那时没有基督引导他们去见上帝.

在神圣的星期六,他(耶稣)在地狱里,忍受着恶劣环境,抗衡着魔鬼,向人们传福音.
从亚伯拉罕本人,到孔子、柏拉图和亚里士多德,任何愿意倾听和追随他(耶稣)的人都在周日脱离出了地狱.

Arthur Mosley Sr.
No.
However, if you are a Christian, Moslem, or part of any religion that believes in a hell, then you will think, or “believe”, you or someone you know or of whom you have heard are going to hell, but, in reality, hell is actually experienced on Earth and on other planets in galaxies far, far away. Not under the ground in the center of the Earth.A friend of mine lost his 23 year-old son to drugs a few months ago. He definitely feels he is in hell.However, I am sure you can think of some experiences you have had during your time on this earth that you would call heaven.A God worth worship would not send anyone to what is thought of as hell for eternity. No God worth worshiping would snuff out the eternal awareness of a soul for eternity. Sooner or later, we all will see the error of our ways, decided to suffer no more, and choose to be the best conduits possible, for us, of the desire and the will of God through and as us.God does not punish. God educates. It is just that sometimes the education is seen as punishment. Define it as punishment and experience it as hell. Define it as an opportunity for spiritual growth, embrace that which is in front of you, look for the treasure in the center of what we call tragedy and you will eventually see God smiling at you from the core of the experience.


Jim Noblett
But to be fair, you also go to hell when you die even if you did know and obey God.That''s because the words sometimes translated as hell (Sheol and Hades)in some bibles is referring to the grave.The Bible says the dead are unconscious (Ecc. 9:5). So when any of us die we go to the grave and wait to be resurrected which the Bibles says will happen for righteous and unrighteous people. (John 5:28,29 acts 14:15)So even if you die without knowing about God, he will resurrect you and youll have the opportunity to learn about him in perfect conditions.

回答4:
公平地说,即使你知道并顺服神,你死后也会下地狱.
这是因为在一些圣经中,地狱有时被翻译成“阴间”,指的是坟墓.

圣经说死者是没有知觉的(第9章5节).
所以,我们任何一个人死后,都会走向坟墓,等待复活,
圣经上说,这将发生在正直和不正直的人身上。(约翰福音5:28,29使徒行传14:15)
所以,即使你死时不认识神,他也会使你复活,你也有机会认识他.

Jacob Stoddard Johnson
You do not understand what Hell is my friend.
If you think that God is willing to torture a soul with incomprehensible pain for an eternity for simply being born in the wrong place, then you misunderstand the nature of God.Here is what Mormons believe: Hell is a reference to one of two places, spirit prison and outer darkness. Everyone not actively faithful in God pretty much goes to SP, but it isnt necessarily that bad of a place. It is a place of learning, repentance, and changing ones life, kind of like Catholic Purgatory but not as scary. The only considerable pain felt is the shame one chooses to feel, which is necessary for change, unless if someone refuses to repent, and there will be people that do ( The Sons of Perdition). People go to SP as soon as they die. Those that don''t got to a preheaven like place known as spirit paradise, which is the safegrounds or temporary home for the righteous spirits that are to go over to SP and teach about the gospel.Outer Darkness is reserved for Satan, his demons, and the Sons of Perdition. Outer darkness is a place without the light of christ aka god’s spirit or the light and life of God. Thats all Mormons have to say about OD. I used to think it was a place of extreme pain, but I actually speculate that it is probably a place of absolute melancholy and nothingness, where the ability to feel things is taken away. Just super depressiveness, but not agony or torture. This is in contrast to Heaven, where one can feel as much joy and/or pain as they please, loosely, recognizing that there are different degrees to glory and principles of functionality might change with them.These beliefs signify of a much more benevolent creator, without taking away from justice and necessity.

回答5:
你们根本就不知道地狱是什么,我的朋友.
如果你认为,仅仅因为某个灵魂出生在错误的地方,
上帝就用痛不甘言的苦难永远地去折磨它,那么,你就误解了上帝的本性.

摩门教徒相信,地狱指的是这两个地方:精神监狱和外部黑暗。
所有对上帝不忠的人去的地方是SP,这个不一定是一个糟糕的地方。
这是一个让灵魂在那里学习、悔改和改变人生的地方,有点像天主教的炼狱,但没有那么可怕.

真正痛苦的是,让人去受辱.
这种痛苦,是必须要避免的.
拒绝忏悔的人才遭到耻辱的痛苦,而人是会忏悔的.

人死之后,去的地方是SP.
这个地方是灵魂去“精神天堂”之前暂时住的地方
这是一个安全的地方,或者是正义的灵魂暂时的家,他们会去SP教福音.
外部的黑暗是属于撒旦管辖的地方,是恶魔和堕落之子的势力范围.
那里是一个没有基督之光的地方,那里也没有生命.

以上就是摩门教徒对OD的全部看法.
我原认为那是一个极度痛苦的地方,
但实际上,我推测那可能是一个绝对忧郁和虚无的地方,
在那里,你再也没有能力去感觉任何事物了.



Cirelda Athalia Gonzalez Martinez
I was planning to just leave it for this is an old question but read some answers which made me stop to write. The answer is NO God will not send anyone to hell. We are not sent anywhere we gain the possibility to go to heaven or hell by the way we live. We get what is worthy! There are a few places we can get as reward. You can find them in the bible, It is very well explained in it. I have two good news for those who are afraid of hell: 1) No hell is not for the one who did not learned the gospel. It is more for those who knew it and disobeyed. Not knowing the gospel is not a reason to go to hell, in fact paradise is the place for those who didn''t learn it and still were good. Christ is the God they will have. Off course there are sins which will condemned to hell people who didn''t know the gospel for they knew what''s bad and right and chose to do wrong but they will be judge with more tolerance than the ones who knew the gospel and sinned.2) The hell everybody is afraid of is not the hell prepared for men. To get to the hell you are afraid of you will have first to learn the whole gospel, gain the way back to God and right on his presence, being a god yourself reject Father in Heaven like Satan did. The ones who left heaven with him are gods subordinated to his command. It is not a place for people without knowledge. I wrote about the hell prepared for men in my blog some time ago. Why don''t you just read it yourself
TO SAY IT WITHOUT ARGUE: About Death And Heaven http://tosayitwithoutargue.blogs...

回答7:
这个是老问题了,本来我不想回答的,但是,看了些评论,让我觉得不吐不快.
这个问题的答案是:不会! 上帝不会把任何人送进地狱.
我们并没有被送入地狱或天堂,我们进入地狱或天堂是自身的生活方式决定的.
我们做过什么,我们就收获什么后果.

有几个乐土让我们进入,那是作为我们(做善事)的一种奖励.
至于这几个乐土在哪里,你们可以去看看圣经,里面解释得很好.

对于那些害怕地狱的人,我有两个好消息:
1. 并没有哪个地狱是为没有闻过福音的人准备的.
地狱只为那些听闻福音而又不遵从福音的人准备着.
未听闻到福音,不是下地狱的罪行!

事实上,天堂是为那些没有学习福音但仍然是好人而准备的地方的.
当然,也有一些罪,会把那些不知道福音的人下地狱的.
那就是,那些人明辨什么是坏的,什么是对的,但他们却选择做错事.
不过,他们会比那些知道福音的人而又故意犯罪的人,得到的审判会更宽容.

2.人人惧怕的地狱,并不是为世人准备的.
要想知道,你会不会被送进人人惧怕的地狱,
你必须先学习整个福音.
像撒旦那样自己是神,却不信奉上帝,那就下地狱了.
那些和他一起离开天堂的人是服从他命令的神.

讨论这些问题,没有知识是不行的.
前段时间我在我的博客里写了关于为世人准备的地狱。
你为什么不自己读呢?
《无可争辩地说:关于死亡与天堂》http://tosayitwithoutargue.blogs..》



Daniel Super
In "Inferno" the 14th century poet Dante Alighieri describes the first level of hell as being the place for people who lived virtuous lives but were unbaptized. This is home to many of the great thinkers and heros of antiquity, and lacks the physical punishments of the deeper levels of hell. The only punishment is that they will never be saved for "they lacked the hope for something greater than rational minds can conceive."

回答9:
在《地狱》一书中,14世纪的诗人但丁,将地狱的第一层描述为那些过着高尚生活但没有受洗的人住的地方.
古代许多伟大思想家和英雄的就住在地狱的这一层.
这一层的人,没有受到那种存在于地狱深处的体罚.

住在这一层的人,受到的唯一的惩罚是,他们永远得不到救赎,
因为“他们缺乏超越理性思维的意愿”



John Callahan
Traditional Dogma suggests this may be the case. I would ask that you and everyone else open their heart & mind to the fact that God is not in need of psychological help. God doesn''t send anyone anywhere, we are responsible for where we go when our time is complete here. God wrote the laws and we are governed by them, so we have a say in our destiny. Just because a book was written as "The Authoritative Guide" doesn''t make it the only source for truth. Just as it is filled with wisdom and much truth doesnt make it all true. There are thousands of ancient texts that provide the simple answer to your question. He would not! The discussion of Heaven and Hell is one far too big for this forum. The data and much wisdom is there if you look in the right places, but you have to be prepared to spend many years searching and reading and not tainted by your Ego''s desire.

回答11:
传统的教义认为可能是这样的.
我建议你和其他人敞开心扉,接受上帝,这不需要心理辅导的.

上帝是不会把任何人送到任何地方,
我们的审判日到了的时候,判定我们去哪里,这是由我们自己平时的行为决定的.

我们受律法支配,而上帝只制定律法,所以我们对自己的命运有发言权.
仅仅因为某本书是“权威指南”,并不意味着它就是唯一的真理.
因为某书充满智慧,富有哲理,并不意味着这本书就全是真理.

楼主,你的这个问题,有成千上万的古代文献为你的问题提供了简洁的答案.
那就是:上帝不会送未闻福音的人下地狱!

天堂和地狱这个主题太大了,我们这个论坛是讨论不了的.
如果你找到讨论这个主题的正确地方,那么,那里就有很多的资料、智慧供你吸取.
但是,你必须有思想准备,那就是,要探究这个问题,你得花费多年时间去探究、阅书.
不要被你的自我欲望蒙蔽了自己的心智.
收藏译文
评论暂时关闭,登录 后进行查看